AILMENT OF THE
I decided a
year ago to stick to only Region 2 DVD's after reading the pros and cons of R1
vs R2. One difference I was unaware of until recently has made me question
whether R2 is after all the best choice on technical grounds. The US and UK TV
systems run at different frequencies and have different lines of resolution. As
a result we benefit from a noticeably improved image quality and see a smoother
picture. However our image rate (and audio) has to be speeded up. The US
versions get around this and are exactly the same as the original movie - the
reason why R1's Gladiator is 6 minutes longer than R2's.
I am debating
whether our loss of audio fidelity, reduced running time (and fewer extras) is
more important than the benefits in picture quality we enjoy. Can you please
clear up this issue, as I don't know whether to replace my 30 R2 discs and chip
my player before I buy any more discs e.g. Star Wars.
Six of one and
half a dozen of the other… When a movie (shot at 24 frames per second) is
transferred to PAL DVD (and VHS tape) it is sped up by 4% to match the 25fps
frame rate of PAL, which means you loose precisely 2 minutes and 24 seconds per
hour and if uncorrected music and voices would be almost a halftone higher in
pitch. In practice most people do not notice the increase in speed. Changes to
the audio – also barely noticeable -- can (or should be) be corrected during
the mastering process. Transferring a movie to NTSC, to match the 30 frames per
second rate is much more complicated and entails juggling the times each frames
of movie film is shown during the conversion process. There is also a small
timing error, though since it only amounts to 3.6 seconds per hour it is of no
consequence. However, the conversion does have a noticeable effect on pans and
rapid movement, which can sometimes look quite jerky.
prefer PAL since as you say the picture is crisper and I'm usually more
interested in watching the movie to worry about a few lost minutes, in fact I
count it as a bonus on some films… I certainly wouldn't recommend that you
replace 30 R2 movies on such a minor pretext, but there's no reason why you
shouldn't get your player chipped or hacked if the movies you want to see are
out first, or only available from the US.
I buy many DVD's each year and I look after them well. But lately I have
noticed faint surface scratches on my DVD's and I am starting to worry. How
long is a DVD meant to last? I use everything available on the market to clean
my DVD's (fluid etc). I was even considering buying a DVD-RW and copying my
DVD's which would be extremely expensive, but in the end I thought I shouldn't
have to do that as why pay out for the DVD and then have to back it up. Will
these surface scratches affect the play of the DVD? I think for £20 they should
last forever, especially my rare ones.
Stockton, via email
forever, ask anyone with collection of Betamax or V2000 tapes or Laserdiscs and
in ten years what will you play your VHS tapes on? The point is the software --
i.e. your DVDs – should comfortably outlive the hardware, which typically has a
25-year life cycle. In fact there is evidence to suggest that properly stored
audio CDs and DVDs should last for at least 50 years. Light scratches and
surface scuffing is not normally a problem as DVD players have very powerful
error correction. You will notice it when the scratches are big or deep enough
to cause a major loss of data, the picture will pixellate (break up into
coloured blocks) and in more serious cases it may also skip, freeze or jump.
If discs are
handled carefully scratching shouldn't occur. It is just possible that your player
is responsible; it's worth checking the surface of the loading tray that comes
into contact with the disc. I have also noticed that some cheapie players have
poorly designed deck mechanisms and the disc is sometimes still spinning on the
tray after it is ejected; this can't do the surface of the disc any good.
protection systems on DVD recorders and PCs with DVD burners will prevent you
from 'backing up' your discs but in any case this would be an extremely
expensive business and blank DVDs currently cost more than most movies moreover
the dust has yet to settle over the different recordable DVD formats.
About a year ago I bought via an Internet order a multi-region DVD player,
which was then the recommended best buy in one of the major magazines. It
is a Mico model A980 and initially worked excellently. Now it has developed
a fault since as it gets warm an increasing number of red and green lines
show up on the screen until it is virtually obliterated.
Unusually for me, since I normally hoard paper, I have lost the receipt and
having had an e-mail problem recently I no longer have a record of where it
came from (lessons to be learnt from both of these). The instruction booklet
has no manufacturers address or detail of a service agent. Can you suggest
somewhere I can get it repaired, preferably in London?
David Hutchings, East Bergholt, Suffolk
A980 was sold exclusively online by Unbeatable.co.uk (http://www.unbeatable.co.uk) the player
has since been discontinued but the company is still going strong and if you
can't get to its web site or send an email (firstname.lastname@example.org)
then you can write to them at: Unbeatable.co.uk,
Capital House, Link 10, Napier Way, Crawley, West Sussex RH10 9RA or telephone
since the machine is now over a year old and presumably out of guarantee
(unless you also took out an extended warranty), Unbeatable is obviously under
no obligation to repair it, however it does have its own service department,
which can be contacted on 020 8687 8871. Alternatively almost any competent
service engineer should be able to fix it for you since as I recall when I
reviewed it last year, it used reasonably common parts. One word of caution,
though, get an estimate first before you part with any money. The A980 was a
budget player and not an especially memorable one at that; if the repair comes
to more than £30 to £50 say, I would suggest you cut your losses, save your
money and put it towards a new player. Budget models with at least the same and
in some cases better performance and facilities as the A980 are now available
for a little over £100.
I heard rumours
that the Region 1 Finding Forrester is encoded with a virus that once played in
a multi-code/region-free player will be crippled by it. Is this possible? Is
this Hollywood's plan B after Region Enhancement Code to discourage exports of
Region 1 discs?
Douglas Tseng, via email
haven't heard that one before; it's almost as good as the tales about viruses
infecting mobile phones and lifts in office blocks… Even if it were possible to
plant a virus in a DVD player (which it is not) I would be fascinated to see
how the studio responsible handled the flood of litigation and lawsuits.
NOT SO SEXY
purchased Sexy Beast to play on my Sony S525 and found that the disc would not
start. Over the past couple of years I have had three discs with this problem
Galaxy Quest, Stereophonics The Videos and Never Say Never Again (the last
probably being a good thing). I am a keen fan of films on DVD and now have over
300 discs so 4 duff ones is not too bad but I felt I had to write as I read
some great reviews of Sexy Beast and really wanted to see it. I was wondering
if anyone else had this problem?
It would be a
great shame if we couldn't enjoy this year's big titles -- The Phantom Menace,
Godfather Trilogy etc – due to this problem. Why can't the manufacturers make
sure all discs are of the same quality and why can't they test their discs on a
range of DVD players? If they don't work they could put a 'Not compatible
with…' sticker on the packaging and this would stop customers being
As you say 4
out of 300 is not bad, I've checked around and I can't find any problems with
Sexy Beast on Sony players, or any other makes for that matter so I suspect
it's a one-off fault and you should get the disc changed. Nevertheless if
anyone has had a similar problem to Garry I'd like to hear from you.
I'm not about
to make any excuses for the DVD industry but you have to bear in mind that this
is still a relatively new technology and the specs for both players and discs
are open to a certain amount of interpretation which has led to the occasional
conflict. The good news is that it's happening less frequently these days – a
year or so ago these pages were filled with tales of woe about discs that
wouldn't play on particular players. Most of the problems I've encountered
lately were in fact due to disc manufacturing faults or careless handling or
storage. Try the obvious first, change the disc and run a cleaner disc through
your player before you start blaming the hardware.
I'd like to recommend
this Canadian R1 DVD Site: Total Action Universe: http://www.totalactionuniverse.com.
Delivery time is 4-6 Days, and postal charges are between £3 (for 1 disc) and
£6 (2 or more DVDs). For example, The Mummy Returns is available on Pre-order
on R1 DVD for £14.92. I used to use DV-Depot but I have found that Total Action
Universe DVD's are often around £1-£4 cheaper.
that, all recommendations, and warnings, gratefully received.
I'm new to this
DVD lark, and have recently acquired a lovely Samsung DVD-M105. The manual says
that I can play NTSC discs via its Quasi
PAL mode. Is this the same thing as multi region? Can I play any disc from
region one? If not, do you know of a hack for this model? Also, before you
go, just how risky are these hacks? Can you really harm your player using
one? So many questions...
NTSC replay is
quite different from Regional Coding; this simply means it can replay a Region
2 NTSC disc on a PAL TV. However, the M105 can be handset hacked for all-region
or Region 1 replay. Proceed as follows: switch on (tray empty) press and hold
Play and Stop on the front panel until the language menu appears, select 1 for
English the on the handset press Repeat, 3, 8, 7, 6, 7 followed by the region
number (1 to 6) or 9 for all regions, then press Open on the player and Standby
on the remote. If you change to R1 you will need to substitute the code 2, 9,
3, 3, 4 to get it back to R2.
We make no
claims for the safety or veracity of any of the hacks we publish and you use
them at your own risk but in general there's little that can go wrong if you
follow the instructions as in most cases all you are doing is changing an
option on a hidden 'Service Menu'.
I have recently
purchased the Hitachi DVP515 and am desperate to know if
there is a way to unlock the machine to play region 1 DVD's?
Shaun Goulding, via email
It's your lucky
day; try the hack for the Samsung DVD-M105 (above)
My friend reads What DVD and she says she got
help, via yourselves, with a 'code' that switched regions on her DVD player? I
have just purchased a Wharfedale DVD-M5, is there such a code for my machine?
Martyn Hodgson, via email
There is but I'll only divulge it on the
strict understanding that you promise to become a regular reader from now on,
and no pinching your friend's copy! To get to the Service Menu press Setup 6,
2, 8, 3, 6, make your change (Region 1 to 6 or 'All') and press Setup again to
recently made the (long-time coming) leap from Laserdisc to DVD and purchased a
second-hand Aiwa XD-DV290. The
instructions claim that this is a Region 2 only machine and is not compatible
with NTSC or SECAM discs. I know this isn't true because I've already played
the Region 0 (NTSC) version of Robocop. Obviously I'm desperate for an all
region decode so I can start buying discs from abroad. I've already tried a
hack for the Aiwa 370 that brings up a version info screen, but I don't seem to
be able to change any of the settings.
Trawling the net has proved fruitless... help me Doctor, you're my only
T. Lane, Northamptonshire
I hate to be
the bearer of bad news but like you I've searched high and low for a hack for
this machine but with no luck, sorry.
brought issue 28 of What DVD. I tried the code you gave for the Hitachi DV-P305
in Crack Code clinic, in fact I have tried it a dozen times and it definitely
does not work. Could there be another code or does it only work on certain
The code as
printed was correct and it's normally very reliable, however as with all of the
hacks we publish they're not guaranteed as changing the region code on a DVD
player is an unadvertised and unapproved procedure. It is quite possible that
the manufacturers have changed the firmware on this machine (firmware is the
software that controls how the player works), in which case it may no longer be
possible, however I'm not aware of that happening and it's something that
usually gets flagged up quite quickly on the various newsgroups on the
Internet. I'd try it again, don't rush it and make sure you follow the
instructions to the letter.
Ó R. Maybury 2001, 0609